5 employee survey mistakes that are costing you good people

Here's a short list for HR and People teams who want their next round of employee feedback to actually change something.

Because if your last round ticked a box, produced a nice chart and then not much else, here's where to look before the next one goes out.

1. You're not asking often enough

Feedback works best close to the moment it happens; a manager can fix a bad week if they hear about it in week two, but not in a report the following quarter.

So cut down the questions and move to monthly or fortnightly pulses instead; fortnightly for fast-moving teams, monthly for more established teams.

I always like to tell our customers here at Teamgage that smaller gaps between surveys help you catch smaller problems. Something to remember?!

2. Your questions measure feelings, not behaviour

"Rate your engagement out of 10" gives you an abstract number nobody can act on.

So we always want to help our customers ask something their managers can really work with instead. For example "how supported do you feel in managing your job demands?" Things like feeling supported, removing frustrations and working within teams that live your values are what makes good people stick around!

In my experience, questions that can provide a rating and that constructive, action-orientated feedback always work best.

We actually get so much of it in our customer's Teamgage results, we've had to build features to allow leaders to either reply back to all of the great insights and ideas generated, or add them directly into our team actions tracker so they can be monitored and fulfilled.

3. The data goes to HR before it goes to managers

Most platforms send results up the chain only; managers then get a filtered summary from HR weeks later, if they see it at all. Again we want to close that gap so team Managers can build their own leadership skills and run the actual improvement process with their team day-to-day.

To do that, they need their own data closer to real time, not a version HR has already smoothed over for a leadership pack.

So give managers more access to their own team's numbers and let them act on what they see, without waiting for someone three levels up to translate it into a slide. A manager who can see their own team insights dip in real time can have a conversation about it that afternoon, not next quarter.

And if you need to upskill your leaders to handle their own survey feedback, our Teamgage experts can host tailored 2-hour Leader Labs to cover topics like building team engagement, reducing staff turnover and generating high performance.

4. You never close the loop

Nothing kills participation like silence. Ask people for feedback, do nothing visible with it, and response rates drop the next round; people stop bothering once they decide nothing changes.

It also tends to encourage complaints because it feels like everything disappears into a black hole anyway. Teams don't ever need to be accountable for creating more action-orientated survey responses.

Flip that and make sure your teams know exactly what you heard, even when the honest answer is "we cannot move on this piece of feedback this quarter, and here's why."

A short update beats a long survey that nobody trusts and always leads to more constructive feedback over time.

5. The survey takes ten minutes to finish

Long surveys get abandoned halfway through, or answered on autopilot by question thirty, just to make the progress bar move. It means that things that may be getting in the way of your employees doing their best work, causing them frustrations or even making them concerned; don't get raised in the way they should.

Seven sharp, relevant, focused questions written in your own organisation's tone of voice every month, beat fifty questions once a year, every time.

Short surveys respect people's time; people repay that with a more honest answer, not a rushed one just to reach the finish line. So if a survey takes longer than a coffee break, it's probably too long.

‍

So get all this right, and your next survey will tell you something the last five didn't!